New York Pizza Company Menu (Update 2026)

New York Pizza Company serves up an incredible variety of pizzas that captures the essence of New York style. From the classic cheese pizza to specialty options like the Hot Honey Pepperoni or the indulgent Meat Pie, there's something for every taste. Pizza lovers can fully customize their pies, choosing from a selection of toppings that include fresh veggies, savory meats, and more. If you're in the mood for quick bites, grab a slice of cheese or pepperoni pizza, conveniently available by the slice. Don't forget to complete your meal with a creamy New York cheesecake for dessert. There's something satisfying about having a mix of traditional and creative choices, all under one roof.

All Day - Create Your Own Pizza
All Day - Specialty Pizzas
All Day - Authentic Specialty Pies
All Day - Dessert
All Day - Beverages
All Day - SIDES
All Day - APPETIZERS - SHAREABLES - SPECIALS
All Day - VIRTUAL SLICE COUNTER
All Day - BEER GARDEN

Featured Dishes

Margherita Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Sausage & Mushroom 14 Pizza NY Thin Crust Medium 14
Sausage & Mushroom 14 Pizza NY Thin Crust Medium 14
Salad Meat Margherita White Pie
Salad Meat Margherita White Pie
Sweet Sausage Pizza
Sweet Sausage Pizza
Spicy Italian Sausage and Jalapeno
Spicy Italian Sausage and Jalapeno
Meat Pie
Meat Pie
New York Pizza Company Menu image 1
New York Pizza Company Menu image 2
New York Pizza Company Menu image 3
New York Pizza Company Menu image 4
New York Pizza Company

New York Pizza Company Interior, Food, Ambiance

Upon entering New York Pizza Company, the aroma of fresh pizza greets you, making it an inviting spot for all pizza enthusiasts. The interior reflects a casual yet vibrant atmosphere, encouraging families and friends to come in, unwind, and enjoy their meal. Large tables accommodate hungry groups, and wall decor pays homage to iconic New York landmarks, adding to the city's ambiance. Natural light floods the dining area, making it a welcoming space for a leisurely lunch or dinner. As people gather over slices and good conversation, the restaurant becomes a hub of local camaraderie, enhancing the overall pizza experience and making it a true slice of community.

New York Pizza Company

About New York Pizza Company Food and Specialties

The food at New York Pizza Company truly captures the spirit of its namesake city. The standout is the XL Large 20" New York Thin Crust Cheese Pizza, perfect for sharing or satisfying an enormous appetite. The specialty pizzas bring unique flavors to the table; the Hawaiian Lovers Pizza combines sweet and savory together harmoniously. Each pie boasts fresh ingredients, from the tangy sauce to the rich cheese. The new crispy banana peppers and imported pepperoncinis offer a delightful crunch that elevates the dining experience. If you're a fan of pizza that really hits the spot, this local gem provides an authentic taste without crossing state lines.

New York Pizza Company

New York Pizza Company is committed to delivering the real deal when it comes to New York-style pizza. Each ingredient gets careful selection to ensure quality, from their thin crust dough to the freshest toppings. Customers recognize this dedication, making it a leader in serving authentic, hearty pizza dishes within the community. The restaurant’s specialty lies in its variety, maintaining true authenticity while also taking creative risks with unique flavors, such as the Hot Honey Pepperoni and Grandma Pie.

The vision centers around creating a friendly, welcoming environment where everyone feels at home.

It's not just a place to eat; it's a vibrant community gathering spot where lifelong memories can be made over shared slices of pizza. From the bustling atmosphere on busy weekend nights to the casual vibe during quieter afternoons, New York Pizza Company aims to be a pivotal part of the local food scene in Louisville, bringing a taste of New York to everyone’s plate.